MagikMagik vs Minta
We make Magik. Minta is built around a genuinely useful idea — turning a catalogue into video ads at volume — that just isn't the same thing Magik does. Here's where each one actually wins.
Where Minta wins
- Video ads from a catalogue, at scale. Built to turn a large product catalogue into template video ads efficiently — a genuinely different use case from organic posting.
- Pinterest. Covers Pinterest on top of the core networks, which Magik does not.
Where Magik wins
- AI creator videos, not template video. Minta's video is template-style — product shots assembled into a video ad. Magik generates a presenter-style clip built to look like organic creator content, which is what earns reach on TikTok and Reels rather than reading as an ad.
- Built for organic posting, not just ad creative. A daily calendar of content meant to be watched and followed, not a batch of ad variants.
- Auto-reply to comments on Facebook and Instagram, in your brand voice, the moment they're posted — from Standard upward.
- A calendar you edit before anything publishes, rather than a batch export.
What we won't claim
We don't run Minta ourselves, so we won't invent specifics about its pricing or exact catalogue-scale limits. If bulk video ads from a large catalogue is the job, check Minta's own Shopify listing directly.
How to decide
If you're producing paid ad creative from a big catalogue at volume, that's Minta's actual strength. If you want a daily organic presence — content that looks like it belongs in the feed, not an ad, plus comments answered automatically — that's what Magik is built for. Both have free plans.